Should We Break Up or Stay Together?
Can this Relationship be Saved? Should We Breakup or Stay Together?
Are you asking yourself “should we breakup of stay together?” As a couples counselor and discernment counselor, I have clients who also ask this question.
“Do we break up or stay together?”
If you’ve been going through some hard times in your relationship, you’ve probably wondered this recently.
In fact, you might even have moved on to bigger questions. Questions like, should you break up or stay together? Is it worth it? How can you tell? Which signs indicate that a relationship is meant to last, and which means that it’s time to call it quits?
Let’s clear a few of those questions up today.
All Relationships Go Through Hard Times
I’ve been a breakup and divorce counselor for years, a discernment counselor for over a decade, the author of Exaholics: Breaking Your Addiction to an Ex Love, and a married person for even longer than that. And I can say, with confidence, that all relationships go through hard times. Any couple (and a lot do) could find themselves at the cross street of moving forward or parting ways – many wonder should we breakup or stay together. So, if you are finding yourself in this moment now, know that you’re not alone.
Even strong, healthy couples — with a lifetime of love ahead of them — can have weeks, months, or even years where they do not feel good about their partnership. It’s true! Even THAT couple has wondered whether they should breakup or stay together.
Communication is hard, and even the most committed partners will experience some growing pains as they truly get to know each other. Unfortunately, sometimes people think that this natural stage is a sign that they aren’t compatible, and they call things off before their relationship has a chance to evolve.
This is normal. But couples who don’t break up, who commit to solving their problems and growing together, can emerge from hard times having grown as people, with stronger relationships than ever before. I’ve seen it happen, and it’s happened in my own marriage. Not getting along for a spell does not necessarily mean you should break up.
So for the rest of this article, let’s break down which signs indicate a potential growth opportunity for your relationship, and which mean that you and your partner are truly incompatible.
How Do You Know It’s Time to Break Up?
Here are ten questions to ask yourself as you decide whether to work on your relationship, or end it:
- Does my partner fundamentally prioritize my wellbeing?
- Am I being treated with love and respect?
- Have I communicated my feelings and needs openly with my partner?
- How does my partner respond when I ask for what I need?
- Do we share long-term goals and values?
- Am I holding on to this relationship out of love, fear, obligation, or convenience?
- Are the issues we’re facing things that are unique to this relationship? Or things I’m likely to experience in my next relationship?
- What have I done to resolve the issues in this relationship?
- Is my partner committed to working toward positive change in our relationship? Am I?
How to Tell: Should We Breakup or Stay Together?
All relationships go through rough patches. And while many rough patches are actually an opportunity for growth, there are situations where a relationship is too far gone to be salvaged. Can you solve your relationship problems without breaking up? There are partnerships where partners are fundamentally incompatible. And there are toxic, unhealthy relationships that aren’t good for anyone. Sometimes, breaking up is the best thing for both of you.
But it can be hard to decipher which rough patches are “normal” relationship turbulence, and which are red flags that mean you should break up. Things get even more complicated when you add factors like children or shared living situations into the mix.
Even when it seems like breaking up is clearly the only option, people still wonder if they’re doing the right thing, or if they should give their relationship just one more chance.
Because deciding “should we breakup or stay together” is such a hard decision, we dedicated an entire podcast to answering all of your questions about when to stay and when to call it quits. In the podcast, we answer questions like:
- “How long should it take to see improvement in my relationship?”
- “In my heart, I don’t want to be married to this person anymore. Will our love ever come back? Can this marriage be saved?”
- “Is what I’m seeing solvable, or is this a sign that we should break up?”
- “Once a cheater, always a cheater? Can you have a good relationship after infidelity?”
- “I’m not being treated well by my boyfriend. Can this change?”
- “How do I know if I’ve tried hard enough to save my relationship?”
- “Should I follow my head, or my heart?“
So if you’ve been going through a hard time in your relationship, and you’re questioning whether to breakup or stay together, go forward with your partner or look elsewhere, I hope that this episode of the Love, Happiness and Success Podcast can help you decide if it’s time to break up, or if your relationship can be saved after all.
Sincerely,
P.S. — Couples counseling is not just for married people. Working with a marriage and family therapist is how couples find their opportunities for growth and strengthen their relationships so that they can stand the test of time. If you’d like support from a couples counselor on my team, I invite you to schedule a free consultation.
Listen & Subscribe to the Podcast
Should We Break Up or Stay Together?
Free, Expert Advice — For You.
Subscribe To The Love, Happiness, and Success Podcast
Episode Highlights: Should We Breakup or Stay Together?
- Two Kinds of Relationships
- There are two kinds of relationships: normal but challenging and scary, and difficult.
- It’s not always clear-cut, but once one partner is set on ending the relationship, it’s hard to save it.
- You have to make calls on whether what’s happening is simply circumstantial or it recurs too much and is already a deal-breaker.
- When It’s Too Late
- You and your partner might not have understood each other at first due to the lack of communication.
- It also happens that a partner takes the other for granted, especially when there are no complaints or when there is just constant compliance.
- The rule of thumb is, if you can’t be accepting of the other person and you need them to change before you change, then it’s time to end the relationship.
- How To Tell When Dating if you Should Breakup or Stay Together
- There’s a saying in dating: fail fast.
- Dating is an audition: how they treat you now is how they will treat you in the future. Their behavior towards you is unlikely to change.
- No Longer Working– Should We Breakup or Stay Together?
- If you’ve done everything you can to save the relationship, then it’s definitely time to cut ties.
- Even if you say you’re staying in a toxic marriage for your children, it’s also important to remember to model what a healthy relationship looks like for your kids.
- Model a good relationship for them, but also show them what a healthy individual looks like.
Marriage Counseling Questions | Couples Therapy Questions
If you’re considering getting involved in marriage counseling, couples therapy, or relationship coaching you probably have questions! Get your marriage counseling questions answered, right here.
Relationship Advice
Our relationship experts have tons of free, helpful relationship advice on numerous topics to support you both on your journey of growth together. View our relationship advice.
How Healthy Is Your Relationship?
Take our free relationship quiz to discover your strengths and growth opportunities, and get expert recommendations.
When To Get Marriage Counseling?
Was that just a yucky fight? Or is your relationship really in trouble? Here’s how to tell when to get marriage counseling.
What To Expect From Marriage Counseling
Learn what to expect from marriage counseling, from your first free consultation to the triumphant “graduation” from couples therapy.
Relationship Coaching vs. Couples Therapy
What’s the difference between relationship coaching vs couples therapy? Learn about both approaches, and which is right for you.
How to Find a Marriage Counselor
Not all marriage counselors are the same. Getting involved with a bad one can be a disaster. Here’s how to find a good marriage counselor…
Pre Marriage Counseling
Couples counseling before marriage is not the same thing as premarital counseling. Many couples need to grow together before they can move forward.
How Long Does Marriage Counseling Take?
You shouldn’t be in marriage counseling for years. Learn the average length of marriage counseling, depending on your situation, and your relationship goals.
How Marriage Counseling Works
Marriage counseling works, but how? Learn how marriage counseling works, and how the process can help you grow, together.
Does Couples Therapy Work?
Couples who successfully work through rough patches come out stronger than ever before. If you’re wondering, “Does couples therapy work?” read this article for the inside scoop.
Can We Do Marriage Counseling Online?
Online marriage counseling can be incredibly convenient and effective — but not always. Learn when online marriage counseling is the best bet, and when it’s a bad idea…
Can You Do Long-Distance Couples Therapy?
Yes, we provide long-distance couples counseling from all over the world through secure, easy, three-way online video.
Does Insurance Cover Marriage Counseling?
Insurance can pay for marriage counseling (aka, family therapy), but only sometimes. Learn when insurance covers marriage counseling, and when it won’t.
How Much is Marriage Counseling?
Getting expert help for your marriage can be the best, most life-changing decision you ever make. How much do couples therapy and marriage counseling cost? Get all the details, here.
Gift Relationship Help
If you have a loved one who is struggling in their relationship, you can help them get help by “gifting” couples counseling or coaching. Here’s how…
Discernment Counseling For Couples
Before marriage counseling can work, both partners need to want it to work. Discernment counseling helps you resolve ambivalence, and get clarity.
Why Evidence-Based Therapy Matters
Marriage counseling can be a huge waste of time if your counselor doesn’t practice evidence-based approaches to marriage counseling. Here’s why…
Online Couples Therapy
We offer Denver couples therapy and Denver marriage counseling as well as online couples therapy. Learn about our online couples therapy services.
Our Relationship Services
We offer premarital counseling, sex therapy, perinatal counseling, parent coaching, affair recovery, blended family counseling, financial therapy for couples, and more. Learn about all our couples counseling services.
Meet our Relationship Experts
Growing Self relationship experts are marriage and family therapists with specialized training and experience in effective, evidence-based approaches to help couples grow, together. Meet our team of relationship experts…
The Best Marriage Counseling
Curious to hear what others have to say about their experience with “the best marriage counselor?” Read their stories…
Free Resources, For You.
Our experts are incredibly generous and have put together an entire library of free resources and actionable advice to support you on your quest for Love, Happiness, and Success. View our blog + podcast.
More Questions? Let’s Talk.
We’re available by phone, email, and chat, and happy to answer any of your questions personally. Get in touch, anytime.
Start Couples Counseling or Coaching
Ready to begin marriage counseling, couples therapy, or relationship coaching with Growing Self? Start by scheduling a free consultation meeting with the expert of your choice.
Amazing podcast! <3
Hi Dr. Bobby!
I believe you touched on this topic in this podcast a bit as well as other’s; however, I have been in a 6+ year relationship and about a month ago I ended things with him. Long-story short, problems started in our relationship a few years ago and I didn’t know how to articulate those feelings and needs to him early on in the relationship. About 3 years in, I began asking for couples counceling, then started seeking my own individual counseling, reading relationship articles, blogs, podcasts, and books trying to educate myself how to handle different situations and better our relationship. I was not met with the same effort on his side which has caused a lot of unbalance in our relationship the last 2 years.
Unfortuantely, it got to a point about a month ago where I ended things with him but was asked to give him one final chance. I decided I needed space from him and relationship so we are on a “break”. However, he is now reading a book I’ve been asking him to read, just starting to seek his own individual counseling, and scheduling couples counceling. All this is great news, right?! Then why am I feeling skeptical, in a self-protection mode, and like the work he is putting in NOW is coming from a place of trying to keep me hooked?
I thought this is what I wanted to see and work on with him and now I’m feeling unmotivated to do MORE and put MORE effort into this.
I guess my question is, are these feelings I’m having normal and can be worked through or something different?
Thank you,
Taylor
Taylor, thanks for getting in touch with this question. Yes, unfortunately your experience is a common one: Wanting and hoping and trying and fighting for a relationship, in vain, only to call it quits… and then all of a sudden have your partner VERY MOTIVATED to do all the things you’d asked of him. Except that now, you just don’t trust / care / love anymore. I wish, for both of your sakes, that he’d been willing to do this work with you sooner. (That is why I’m constantly harping on the “don’t wait too long for couples counseling” soap-box).
I don’t know if you can resurrect your feelings for him. It may be too late. If I was your therapist, I’d want to know things like: How committed are you to this? Do you have children together? What’s the risk of trying vs cutting him loose? Do you still feel angry? (Anger can actually be a good sign). Et cetera.
If you would like to try and see if you can get back in the ring with him emotionally, I would encourage you to find a marriage counselor who excels in Emotionally Focused Coupes Therapy. On our team, Brenda Fahn, Teena Evert, and Seth Bender are all good choices for that. Here’s more info…
But your feelings are not a switch that can be flipped on and off. It took you a long time to get here, and it will be a process to see if they can come back to life. Six years is a long time, and I can understand why you’d like to at least see if this can be mended. However, that said, if you two really get engaged with good couples counseling you should know within a period of 2-3 months of weekly sessions if movement is possible. If not, it’s probably a good sign that you release him back to the universe. IMO. All the best to you both, Lisa
Amazing podcast! <3
Hi Dr. Bobby!
I believe you touched on this topic in this podcast a bit as well as other’s; however, I have been in a 6+ year relationship and about a month ago I ended things with him. Long-story short, problems started in our relationship a few years ago and I didn’t know how to articulate those feelings and needs to him early on in the relationship. About 3 years in, I began asking for couples counceling, then started seeking my own individual counseling, reading relationship articles, blogs, podcasts, and books trying to educate myself how to handle different situations and better our relationship. I was not met with the same effort on his side which has caused a lot of unbalance in our relationship the last 2 years.
Unfortuantely, it got to a point about a month ago where I ended things with him but was asked to give him one final chance. I decided I needed space from him and relationship so we are on a “break”. However, he is now reading a book I’ve been asking him to read, just starting to seek his own individual counseling, and scheduling couples counceling. All this is great news, right?! Then why am I feeling skeptical, in a self-protection mode, and like the work he is putting in NOW is coming from a place of trying to keep me hooked?
I thought this is what I wanted to see and work on with him and now I’m feeling unmotivated to do MORE and put MORE effort into this.
I guess my question is, are these feelings I’m having normal and can be worked through or something different?
Thank you,
Taylor
Taylor, thanks for getting in touch with this question. Yes, unfortunately your experience is a common one: Wanting and hoping and trying and fighting for a relationship, in vain, only to call it quits… and then all of a sudden have your partner VERY MOTIVATED to do all the things you’d asked of him. Except that now, you just don’t trust / care / love anymore. I wish, for both of your sakes, that he’d been willing to do this work with you sooner. (That is why I’m constantly harping on the “don’t wait too long for couples counseling” soap-box).
I don’t know if you can resurrect your feelings for him. It may be too late. If I was your therapist, I’d want to know things like: How committed are you to this? Do you have children together? What’s the risk of trying vs cutting him loose? Do you still feel angry? (Anger can actually be a good sign). Et cetera.
If you would like to try and see if you can get back in the ring with him emotionally, I would encourage you to find a marriage counselor who excels in Emotionally Focused Coupes Therapy. On our team, Brenda Fahn, Teena Evert, and Seth Bender are all good choices for that. Here’s more info…
But your feelings are not a switch that can be flipped on and off. It took you a long time to get here, and it will be a process to see if they can come back to life. Six years is a long time, and I can understand why you’d like to at least see if this can be mended. However, that said, if you two really get engaged with good couples counseling you should know within a period of 2-3 months of weekly sessions if movement is possible. If not, it’s probably a good sign that you release him back to the universe. IMO. All the best to you both, Lisa